Tuesday, July 28, 2015

To the Parents of NT Children: How You React Matters! Autism Acceptance, con't

Captain Gilly Wants You to Know He's Really Not the Enemy
Mandatory education shoves everyone together. Diminishing SpEd ranks mean more disabled kids in classrooms, and less staff to manage their behavior properly, which leads to more of a chance of a culture of resentment developing.

We have to get past that outside the schools.

The schools have no choice, and the kids in them have no choice:  they all have to be clumped together for 6 1/2 to 8 hours a day, five days a week, 180 days a year.  If things go wrong in the classroom, it is a very different "wrong" than the NT(neuro-typical, i.e., NOT spectrum children) may have any insight into whatsoever.

Judged swiftly and harshly many times, the spectrum kids are often whisked off to another room, like they did something wrong.  It's not that THEY did anything wrong necessarily.  Even if they did, the solutions to keeping it from occurring again are complex and must be implemented by people who understand how the autistic mind works.  It could be that their accommodations have failed, that teachers were not able to apply them adequately, or even that there is some unknown random disabling factor that led to an incident in a classroom.

Blaming and shaming are pointless.  Half the time the ASD child cannot even adequately recall what happened in the first place, because their focus is on some minutiae that isn't even important.

Parents at home may hear stories about the spectrum kid in their child/children's classroom and draw erroneous conclusions based on those stories.  It is VERY unlikely that an NT child has a clue what actually happened and their narrative of what they remember probably bears little resemblance to the actual situation.  There is also the added difficulty that teachers and staff are somewhat bound by privacy laws not to explain things adequately.  Sometimes, it might be helpful for a parent who feels like their child was harmed somehow to hear that the incident in the room that concerns them was not directed AT their child, and was the result of a series of stimuli that added up to a meltdown.  They might also need to hear the timeline to assure themselves that the meltdown was brief and managed properly.  I think explaining HOW autism works to people with questions, and being specific might help people be more compassionate.  Explanations might also help the parents of neuro-typical children challenge the assumptions their children make in narratives about school days and provide a valuable insight into how all of us can make things better if we try.

I know for my son, there are occasional meltdowns and outbursts.  They are NOT the norm.  They are rare, in well-managed settings.  Unfortunately, they are less rare with teachers who are overwhelmed, staff/teachers who do not believe that autism is the root cause of most difficulties and therefore do not apply the abundant accommodations that make classroom success possible, or situations that no one could control or foresee (the snow cone guy did not come as promised, after two weeks of using potential future snow cones as a behavioral control measure which the behavior specialist would probably have told you was a TERRIBLE idea in the first place...etc.).  When they do occur, my son has his own strategies for calming down, and the SpEd staff who knows him very well, can usually return him to regular life in the classroom quickly.  This has all been dramatically improving with every year.  I know his fellow classmates remember him when he was younger as someone quite difficult to manage, and I do hope that they have noticed how much better he is with each passing year.  He deserves that.  He works hard.

When an NT child is narrating something that happened with the ASD child in their classroom, I can understand the gut check a parent might have about things they are hearing.  I understand because I HAVE an NT child, also, and I had many occasions to react to things she told me.  So, I'm no stranger to the gut check reaction at "stuff that happened at school."  However...I did not allow her to be ugly if we met school kids outside school.

Know this:  when a person on the spectrum loses their temper or reacts badly to change, they are DEEPLY embarrassed and ashamed that they could not keep those feelings a secret.  They are desperate to fit in, just like the others around them, and they often painfully, deeply imagine that when they cannot control impulses, everyone will treat them like they are a failure and not worthy of being part of the community.  It hurts to lose control and yell out, or lose your temper.  It is terrifying.  It is humiliating when you did everything you could to be a good person and be kind to others and be what other people expect.  I know this because he has told me what it is like inside a meltdown.  It is awful.

That awful is why there are SpEd teachers and behavior plans.  If you prevent the things are ARE controllable, meltdowns stop.  Dead.  None happen.  My son is a happy, contributing member of the classroom and no one notices because he is quiet when things are going well.

Now, to the point--- no matter what you heard about school from your NT child, the ASD child at the park or the pool or the playground or the concert or the fireworks show may NOT be anything like the child you heard about from those narratives.  A narrative generated by a child or a teacher who is trapped in a room for 6-8 hours a day is not always a reliable yardstick to assess the person outside of school. In their families, most ASD people are calm, happy, smart, funny, gentle and deeply empathic people.  They LOVE making others happy, and have a great deal to contribute.

If all you have encountered is the narrative of the person in the room you've heard about, and you react without actually interacting or paying attention outside of the room, you will miss out on a friendship, a smile, or just a fun few moments.  The least you can do is not make life MORE difficult by judging the child OR the family.  Autism is hard, and it gets better slowly. 

The conversation will continue....

#learnbeforeyoujudge

14 comments:

  1. 1. Telling parents of NT kids they're always lying about what the ASD in class on any given day? As an opening tactic in a plea for understanding? Really?

    2. Does anybody besides immediate family members and paid therapists/staff find your ASD son calm, happy, gentle, smart and empathetic? Anyone at all?

    (Mom and blood relations aren't exactly unbiased).

    3. Having an ASD doesn't preclude a kid from being a jerk.

    An ASD kid with no friends -- no school, camp, church, Boy Scout troop, etc friends -- friends at all, from anywhere, makes the ASD kid in question is the common denominator.

    (All parents of all kids in your city are cruel/unaccommodating to individuals with SN, every.single.one? Seems statistically unlikely).

    3. "he was younger as someone quite difficult to manage, and I do hope that they have noticed how much better he is with each passing year. He deserves that. He works hard".

    The first sentence could be rephrased as "he spent years terrorizing his classmates, albeit involuntarily, and does so less often now. His classmates are still understandably wary".

    4. When you had only a NT kid, would you have encouraged her to befriend a classmate who behaved like da Creature? After years and years of (involuntary) mistreatment at his hands in class?

    5. Surely you've had a colleagues you're not so fond of and elect not to spend time with outside of work. Don't kids feel the same way?

    #maybeothersHAVEbeenthinkingandcametoaconclusionyoudontlike

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hmmm... it seems that I have a very interested follower, who wants to vent steam about their personal experiences with an individual, generalize it onto someone they either do or do not know, but clearly do not know well, based on the sparsity of actual facts and accountability. Thank you for the attention, I suppose. This is a fairly quiet corner of the internet, not prone to such drama and intrigue.

      I agree that people can be jerks. There is a certain irony in the amount of times that has been said, and the manner it was communicated, in the comments on these twin posts. I like irony, it has its own gravitational pull.

      So, to sum up: you are angry, and feel like you need to be heard. I hear you. I agree that you have a problem with someone in your life. Sadly, it's just not my problem.

      I hope you find peace and healing somehow. I am pretty sure that I can provide you with a fairly steady stream of opportunities to vent. Heaven knows my blog could use the spike in readership. There are probably more healthy ways to express whatever is really bothering you. I encourage you to find them. I hope that you feel better soon, you are clearly in pain and in need of understanding.

      Delete
  2. Great post. Interesting yet pathetic comment, however, and hidden behind the cloak of anonymity to boot. I am reminded of an old Indian saying: "Never criticize a man until you've walked a mile in his moccasins."

    To da momma: don't let the turkeys get you down. You are doing a great job! Love ya! ;)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Awww look at the trolly troll commenting anon. Because they don't have the actual balls to comment with their own picture or their own account or even a variant of their own name.

    I think you, mr or mrs mouse, are the most disgusting kind of coward. If you really mean what you say about Da Creature, you'd not hide behind anonymity.

    But the thing is, you're a coward. Show yourself. Comment using your real account if you really mean what you say. Instead of just being a shit stirrer who is trying to make trouble. I have a feeling you're someone who has given Carleigh trouble before. You are a disgusting, miserable human being who just wants everyone else to be as miserable as they are.

    Far as I see it , unless you can do that, your words have no worth. And you are nothing but a pitiful coward.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The anon thing is annoying, I'll admit. It's a pity, too, because it destroys any hope of resolving a conflict. Cowardice is part of keyboard courage. Taking responsibility for your thoughts, actions, and words takes real courage. Being "out there" as a real person has pitfalls on the net sometimes. I wouldn't trade it for anything, though, because the truth is just lower maintenance.

      Delete
  4. My comment appears to have disappeared. This makes sense to me both as a former childcare provider and as an adult child with 8 younger siblings. Children's perceptions may be their realities, but that doesn't mean that what/how they perceived to happen is actually what happened. Especially since a Neuro-Typical child who is able to focus on their work/the teacher/their friends is probably not focused on what may be happening in/around another student.

    If we judged people of different races, religions, etc... the way my friends have shared they experience judgement based on disabilities there would be hue and cry and in some cases boycotts and massive media coverage.

    We can't do everything, but we can all do something. Sometimes that something is as simple as giving common courtesy to every human you meet.

    And there's a difference between thinking a child is lying and recognizing that children's perceptions aren't always accurate. A child might say "you hate me" if you won't let him eat cake for breakfast, doesn't mean you actually hate them.

    And this post isn't saying that having an ASD = automatic pass from jerkitude, it's saying don't assume jerkitude, and don't assume malicious jerkitude. Everyone deserves to be judged based on your own personal interactions with them, and some people deserve the recognition that they need extra help. We wouldn't blame someone in a wheelchair for being unable to navigate stairs, but many people DO seem to blame children with an ASD for not being able to process stimuli the same way NT children do.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This. ALL OF THIS.

      Delete
    2. The comment function on blogger is a twitchy thing, I've noticed. I am glad you were paying attention to the point of this post. That is encouraging.

      The amount of angry bile that I hear about out there is something that I think all of us will be addressing in the next couple of decades. Eventually, there will be a lot more normal ways of going about our social routines that include strategies for neuro-typical people AND spectrum people to get the best out of their public interactions, but for now, the hatred needs to be named and claimed. I find it interesting how different this issue is from other types of social hatred/discrimination. I have hope that eventually there will be a middle way that emerges. Right now, the crest of the wave is just hitting the high schools. There are so many kids on the spectrum, and they share so many traits. It will be a struggle for the next decade as better treatments are employed and more advocacy is done. Eventually the failures of the early years in the education of the autistic will give way to successes and then we'll have a good look at who is still carrying the torch of vengeance and discrimination.

      Hatred isn't new. It's just how the social machine tries to grind the different out of existence. Hatred endures because it works for a while. Eventually, though, it loses, because change is inevitable.

      Besides, we have much bigger fish to fry in terms of social growth. This one is just one *I* get to talk about. :D

      Thanks, Jennifer! I like what you had to say.

      Delete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I am so new at this commenting business I put my reply in the wrong place. I think I may have done it on the other post too. *sigh* Technolearning curve. Well, won't make that mistake again. I'll make NEW ones! LOL.

      Delete
  6. Dear Anon y Mouse,

    The fact that your first response to someone looking for solace is to blame them for their misfortune is pretty twisted. How did such an unaggressive article offend you to such a degree? Were you personally victimized by an autistic individual? Did the autistic Regina George not let you sit at her table because you weren’t wearing pink? Were you forced to live in constant fear that the unbridled whims of an autistic wildling would make your day a little less enjoyable? Only hurt people try to hurt others. Why don’t you find a group more deserving of ridicule and direct your insults towards them. People like you are the reason why there is a need for change.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. "Did the autistic Regina George..." That right there, I don't care who you are, that's funny. I agree 100% with "Only hurt people try to hurt others." I can't imagine going through life looking for anyone to spew poison at who would listen. That sounds lonely and hard. Thanks for the thoughtful comment!

      Delete
  7. An autistic person has a brain that looks and works differently from the neurotypical brain. There are great gains in perception and this is a cursed blessing--overseeing, overhearing, oversmelling. That makes life a bit tough to handle, especially for a younger person. Where there are deficits, they come in communication and those social skills that neurotypicals learned before they could speak. To name just a bare few things like turn taking in communication, using your face to express emotion, modulating your voice. Posts like this are so very important because to a neurotypical person these skills don't feel like they are learned since everyone else seems to know them and acts accordingly. So to the uneducated, a person with Autism just needs to "act right" and stop being "a jerk." Posts like these need to be written to educate everyone as the first commenter very unknowingly demonstrated.

    ReplyDelete